The Manifestation Trap: Why Your Inner Work Isn’t Working

Summary: You’ve meditated your way to enlightenment, manifested abundance until your vision board caught fire, and inner-worked yourself into a therapeutic coma. So why are you still stuck in the same job, the same relationship patterns, and the same bank balance? Spoiler alert: the universe didn’t get the memo because you forgot to send it via the postal service of intentional action.

Introduction

So you’re scrolling through Instagram at 11 PM, watching someone’s morning routine that includes seventeen different spiritual practices before breakfast. You feel inadequate. Tomorrow, you promise yourself, you’ll wake up at 5 AM, meditate for an hour, journal your gratitudes, and manifest your dream life before your first coffee.

Fast forward six months. Your meditation app congratulates you on your streak, your journal overflows with beautiful intentions, and your vision board looks like a Pinterest masterpiece. Yet your life? Remarkably unchanged.

If this resonates, you’re not alone—and more importantly, you’re not broken. You’ve simply fallen into what I call “the manifestation trap,” a phenomenon I’ve witnessed countless times in my 20 years as a medical doctor specialising in stress management and 10+ years leading transformational retreats along the Camino de Santiago.

Andrew Landon’s Awakening

Andrew Landon discovered crystal healing on a Tuesday. By Thursday, he’d ordered £300 worth of rose quartz, amethyst, and something called “manifestation stones” that promised to align his chakras with financial abundance. The former investment banker turned wellness enthusiast had been on his spiritual journey for three years now, ever since his burnout landed him in my colleague’s emergency room with what he thought was a heart attack.

The morning light filtered through Andrew’s converted London flat, catching the geometric patterns of his newly installed salt lamp. He breathed in the scent of burning sage—his daily cleansing ritual—and settled onto his meditation cushion. The familiar weight of the velvet pillow beneath him, worn smooth from countless morning sessions, grounded him as he closed his eyes.

“I am abundance,” he whispered, feeling the words vibrate through his chest. “I am worthy of infinite prosperity.” The mantra had become second nature, like a prayer he’d inherited from the spiritual podcasts that filled his commute to the part-time consulting work that barely covered his rent.

His phone buzzed softly beside him—another guided meditation notification. Andrew ignored it, sinking deeper into his practice. He could almost taste the success he was manifesting: the metallic tang of champagne at his future book launch, the leather scent of his dream car’s interior, the sound of applause echoing through the conference hall where he’d deliver his first keynote speech.

For forty-five minutes, Andrew existed in this parallel universe where everything was possible. His breath synchronised with his visualisations, his body relaxed into the familiar routine of transcendence. The traffic outside his window faded to white noise; the pressure in his temples—a constant companion since his corporate days—dissolved.

But when he opened his eyes, the same stack of unpaid bills stared at him from his kitchen counter. The same cramped flat surrounded him. The same anxious knot twisted in his stomach as he remembered his dwindling savings account.

“Maybe I need to upgrade my practice,” he murmured, reaching for his laptop. Within an hour, he’d signed up for a £500 shadow work intensive, convinced that healing his relationship with money would finally unlock the abundance he’d been affirming for months.

That evening, Andrew sat in a circle with twelve other seekers, each sharing their deepest traumas with the careful reverence of archaeologists uncovering ancient wounds. The facilitator, draped in flowing fabrics and speaking in whispered tones, guided them through visualisation exercises designed to release limiting beliefs about worthiness.

“Feel into your body,” she instructed, her voice honey-thick with spiritual authority. “What does scarcity feel like? Where do you hold it?”

Andrew felt it everywhere—a cold weight in his chest, a tightness in his throat, a churning in his gut that tasted like his father’s disappointment when he’d left his six-figure salary to “find himself.” He breathed into the sensation, welcomed it, befriended it, just as he’d learned in countless workshops.

“Now release it,” the facilitator continued. “Blow it into this feather and let the universe transform it into abundance.”

Andrew exhaled forcefully, watching his breath ruffle the white feather in his palm. Around him, others sobbed, laughed, and proclaimed their freedom from generational money trauma. He felt… empty. Not enlightened-empty, but hollow-empty, like he’d excavated something precious and found only air.

Three months later, Andrew’s spiritual practice had evolved into a full-time occupation. He woke at 5 AM for meditation, spent an hour on affirmations, another hour journaling, followed by yoga, breathwork, and energy healing videos. By noon, he was spiritually exhausted and financially broke.

His breakthrough came not through another healing modality, but through a question posed by his elderly neighbour, Mrs. Patterson, as he helped her carry groceries up the stairs.

“Andrew, love, you’re always talking about this business you’re starting,” she said, pausing to catch her breath on the landing. “What exactly are you selling?”

The question hit him like cold water. For three years, he’d been preparing to launch his wellness coaching business. He’d healed his trauma, cleared his blocks, aligned his chakras, and manifested his success daily. But he’d never actually created a website, written a business plan, or spoken to a single potential client.

“I’m… I’m still in the preparation phase,” he stammered, tasting the metallic bitterness of his own self-deception.

Mrs. Patterson smiled kindly. “Well, dear, I’ve been preparing to plant my garden for two springs now. But you know what? The flowers only grow when you actually put the seeds in the ground.”

That night, instead of his usual evening meditation, Andrew opened his laptop and wrote his first blog post. It was imperfect, vulnerable, and real. Within a week, he had his first coaching inquiry. Within a month, his first paying client.

The irony wasn’t lost on him—the abundance he’d been trying to manifest for years appeared only when he stopped trying to manifest it and started actually creating it.

From the Camino de Santiago

“I came to Dr. Montagu’s retreat carrying three years of spiritual bypassing disguised as growth. I’d done every healing modality imaginable but couldn’t understand why my life remained stuck in the same patterns. Walking the Camino strips away all pretence—you can’t manifest your way up a mountain. You have to take each step, feel each blister, face each challenge as it comes. By day five, I realised I’d been using spirituality to avoid the very life I was trying to change. The real transformation began when I stopped trying to transcend my problems and started walking through them, one authentic step at a time.”
— Sarah M., Retreat Participant, September 2023

Five Key Takeaways

1. The Preparation Trap

Many people mistake preparation for progress. Endless inner work can become a sophisticated form of procrastination, keeping you perpetually “getting ready” instead of actually doing. Real growth requires both inner awareness and outer action.

2. Spiritual Bypassing Is Real

Psychologist John Welwood coined this term to describe using spiritual practices to avoid psychological work or life challenges. When meditation becomes escapism rather than preparation for engagement, you’re bypassing rather than growing.

3. The Body Keeps Score—And the Bank Account Too

Your nervous system responds to actual safety and security, not visualised ones. While positive thinking has benefits, your stress responses are triggered by real-world circumstances that require real-world solutions.

4. Integration Is Everything

The most profound spiritual insights are worthless if they don’t translate into behavioural change. The bridge between inner transformation and outer manifestation is consistent, aligned action.

5. Discomfort Is the Price of Admission

Growth lives in the space between comfort and overwhelm. If your spiritual practice only feels good and never challenges you to act differently, it’s likely keeping you stuck rather than setting you free.

The Reality Check Exercise

Set aside 30 minutes for this powerful self-assessment:

Step 1: The Time Audit List every spiritual/personal development practice you’ve engaged in over the past three months. Next to each, write the hours per week you’ve invested.

Step 2: The Results Inventory For each practice, honestly assess: What specific, measurable changes has this created in your external reality? Not feelings or insights—actual circumstances.

Step 3: The Action Gap Analysis Identify three areas of your life you’ve been “working on” spiritually. For each, write:

• What inner work have you done?
• What concrete actions have you taken?
• What would someone who didn’t know about your inner work see as evidence of change?

Step 4: The Integration Plan Choose one area where you’ve done significant inner work but taken minimal outer action. Create three specific, measurable actions you could take this week to bridge that gap.

This exercise isn’t about abandoning spiritual practices—it’s about ensuring they serve transformation rather than substituting for it.

---

The Wisdom of Rumi: “Let yourself be silently drawn by the strange pull of what you really love. It will not lead you astray.”

This quote from the 13th-century Persian poet perfectly captures the essence of authentic spiritual living. Rumi speaks not of forcing manifestations or manipulating energy, but of being drawn into aligned action by genuine love and purpose. The “strange pull” he describes isn’t the manufactured enthusiasm of affirmations, but the organic magnetism that emerges when we connect with what truly matters to us.

This wisdom is particularly relevant because it suggests that authentic spiritual living feels less like effortful manifesting and more like following a natural current. When we’re aligned with our deepest values and purposes, right action becomes less forced and more flowing—but it’s still action, still movement in the physical world.

Further Reading

1. “Spiritual Bypassing: When Spirituality Disconnects Us from What Really Matters” by Robert Augustus Masters

This groundbreaking book directly addresses the shadow side of spiritual practice. Masters, a psychotherapist with decades of experience, offers a compassionate but unflinching look at how spiritual practices can become sophisticated avoidance mechanisms.

2. “When the Body Says No: Exploring the Stress-Disease Connection” by Gabor Maté

This groundbreaking work by physician Gabor Maté explores how suppressed emotions and spiritual bypassing can literally manifest as physical illness. Maté’s medical background provides compelling evidence for why authentic emotional processing and real-world change are essential for both psychological and physical health.

3. “Atomic Habits: An Easy & Proven Way to Build Good Habits & Break Bad Ones” by James Clear

Clear’s evidence-based approach to behavioral change provides the perfect complement to spiritual practice. This book shows how small, consistent actions create lasting transformation—offering a practical framework for translating spiritual insights into measurable life changes.

4. “The Drama of the Gifted Child” by Alice Miller

Miller’s classic work reveals how even well-intentioned spiritual seeking can become another form of people-pleasing or perfectionism. Her insights help readers distinguish between authentic self-development and performing spirituality to meet others’ expectations or avoid difficult truths.

5. “Peak Performance: Elevate Your Game, Avoid Burnout, and Thrive with the New Science of Success” by Brad Stulberg and Steve Magness

This book combines ancient wisdom with modern science to show how sustainable high performance requires both inner development and strategic action. It’s particularly valuable for understanding how contemplative practices can enhance rather than replace practical effort.

Research

The integration approach to personal development has growing support in psychological research. Studies on meditation effectiveness have consistently shown that contemplative practices are most beneficial when combined with behavioral interventions rather than used in isolation. Research from Harvard Medical School and other institutions has examined the phenomenon of “spiritual bypassing” – using spiritual practices to avoid psychological work rather than enhance it.

A systematic review published in JAMA Psychiatry found that meditation programs showed moderate evidence for reducing anxiety and depression, but the most significant improvements occurred when meditation was combined with cognitive-behavioral interventions and real-world application of insights gained during practice.

The concept of spiritual bypassing, first coined by psychologist John Welwood, has gained increasing attention in clinical psychology as researchers recognize how spiritual practices can sometimes serve as sophisticated avoidance mechanisms rather than genuine growth tools.” (Senapati, Sampriti, and Morgan Wood. “Balancing Reality and Spirituality.” Translation: The University of Toledo Journal of Medical Sciences, vol. 13, no. S2, May 2025).

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Are you saying spiritual practices are useless?

Not at all. Meditation, breathwork, and inner work are valuable tools for developing self-awareness, emotional regulation, and mental clarity. The issue arises when these practices become substitutes for action rather than preparation for it. Think of them as sharpening your tools—essential, but meaningless unless you actually build something.

Q: How do I know if I’m spiritually bypassing?

Ask yourself: “If someone observed my life from the outside, what evidence would they see of the growth I claim to be experiencing?” If the answer is primarily internal or subjective, you might be bypassing. Real transformation is visible in changed behaviours, relationships, and circumstances.

Q: Can’t positive thinking and visualisation actually create change?

Research shows that visualisation can be helpful when it’s used to rehearse specific actions and problem-solve obstacles. However, fantasy-based visualisation (imagining outcomes without considering the process) can actually decrease motivation by giving your brain a premature reward signal. The key is using these tools to prepare for action, not replace it.

Q: What if I’m dealing with trauma and need to heal before I can act?

Trauma healing is absolutely valid and sometimes necessary before taking certain actions. However, healing and action aren’t mutually exclusive. Often, small, supported actions can be part of the healing process. The question isn’t whether to heal or act, but how to do both in a way that serves your growth.

Q: How do I find the right balance between inner work and outer action?

A good rule of thumb: for every hour spent on inner work, match it with at least 30 minutes of aligned outer action. This doesn’t mean busy work—it means taking steps that directly connect to your insights and intentions. The goal is integration, not perfection.

Conclusion

The spiritual path was never meant to be a refuge from life—it was designed to be a training ground for living more fully. The practices that truly serve us don’t just make us feel better; they make us more effective, more compassionate, and more courageously engaged with the world around us.

In my two decades as a physician and a decade guiding retreats, I’ve learned that the most profound transformations happen not on meditation cushions or in healing circles, but in the messy, imperfect moments when we choose to act from our deepest wisdom. The Camino teaches this beautifully—each step is both a prayer and a practical movement forward.

The invitation isn’t to abandon your spiritual practices, but to let them prepare you for the sacred work of actually living your insights. Your meditation cushion is not your destination—it’s your launching pad.

As I often tell my retreat participants, drawing from my book “After the Divorce -for Men” the most spiritual thing you can do isn’t always the most comfortable thing. Sometimes it’s having the difficult conversation, making the scary phone call, or taking the imperfect action that your inner work has prepared you for.

Your life is waiting for you—not in some future moment when you’re finally healed enough or enlightened enough, but right now, in this beautifully imperfect present moment that calls for both wisdom and action.

---

Ready to bridge the gap between inner transformation and outer change? Join me for the Rediscover Your Natural Rhythm stress relief retreat, where we walk the ancient paths of the Camino de Santiago in southwest France. Here, the journey itself becomes the teacher, showing you how to integrate contemplation with action, wisdom with courage, and inner peace with purposeful living. Because sometimes, the most profound spiritual practice is simply putting one foot in front of the other.