5 Common Time Management Mistakes That Are Secretly Sabotaging Your Peace of Mind

Quick Summary

Tackling time management mistakes isn’t about squeezing yet more into your already busy day—it’s about creating space for what matters. This article explores five critical mistakes that transform productivity systems into stress machines: the multitasking myth, perfectionist planning, the “yes” addiction, technology overwhelm, and energy ignorance. Through Simone’s transformative story and practical exercises, you’ll discover how to shift from frantic doing to intentional being.

Introduction

“The bad news is time flies. The good news is you’re the pilot.” – Michael Altshuler

Here’s a truth that might sting: your time management system is probably making you more stressed, not less.

You’ve colour-coded your calendar, downloaded seventeen productivity apps, and read enough time management books to build a small fortress. Yet somehow, you’re still running on empty, feeling like you’re drowning in a sea of urgent tasks while your important dreams gather dust in the corner.

What if I told you that the very strategies you’re using to “manage” time are actually the culprits behind your overwhelm? That the productivity gurus have been selling you solutions to problems they helped create?

Let me introduce you to Simone Clarkson, whose story will change how you think about time forever.

Simone’s Story: When Productivity Became A Prison

The metallic taste of anxiety coated Simone’s mouth as she stared at her phone screen at 6:47 AM. Forty-three notifications blinked back at her—emails, calendar reminders, social media updates, news alerts—each one demanding immediate attention. The coffee maker gurgled in the kitchen, filling her small London flat with the rich aroma of Colombian beans, but even that familiar comfort couldn’t calm the churning in her stomach.

Simone had always been the organised one. The friend who arrived ten minutes early, the colleague whose desk looked like it belonged in a magazine spread, the woman who had her Christmas shopping done by October. At thirty-four, she was a marketing director at a thriving tech startup, mother to seven-year-old Emma, and the kind of person others turned to when they needed something done “right.”

But this morning, as she mechanically went through her elaborate morning routine—checking three different to-do list apps, reviewing her calendar for the fourth time since waking, and mentally rehearsing her presentation for the 9 AM meeting—something felt terrifyingly wrong.

Her hands trembled slightly as she reached for her perfectly organised planner, its pages filled with colour-coded tasks, time-blocked schedules, and motivational stickers that now seemed childish rather than inspiring. The leather cover, once smooth and reassuring under her fingertips, now felt cold and judgmental.

“Mummy, you’re making that face again,” Emma observed from the kitchen doorway, her small voice cutting through the morning chaos like a bell. She was already dressed for school, her uniform slightly rumpled, clutching her favourite stuffed rabbit with one missing ear.

Simone looked up, catching her reflection in the hallway mirror. Dark circles shadowed her eyes, and her mouth was set in a thin line she didn’t recognise. When had she started looking so… angry? So tired?

“What face, sweetheart?” she asked, forcing a smile that felt like wearing someone else’s clothes.

“The face like when you’re trying to remember everything at once and getting mad that you can’t,” Emma replied with the brutal honesty only children possess. “Like your brain is too full.”

The words hit Simone like a physical blow. Out of the mouths of babes.

She knelt down to Emma’s level, breathing in the sweet scent of her daughter’s strawberry shampoo mixed with the crayon-wax smell that always seemed to cling to her school bag. For a moment, the world slowed down.

“You know what?” Simone said, making a decision that surprised even her. “Let’s be late today.”

Emma’s eyes widened. “Really? But you said being late is—”

“Being late is sometimes exactly what we need,” Simone interrupted, surprising herself with the conviction in her voice. “How about we walk to school the long way? Through the park?”

As they stepped outside, Simone deliberately left her phone in her bag. The morning air was crisp against her skin, carrying the earthy scent of fallen leaves and the distant sound of construction work. Emma skipped beside her, pointing out a robin pecking at breadcrumbs near the park bench, her laughter light and musical.

For the first time in months, Simone noticed things. Really noticed them. The way the autumn sunlight filtered through the oak trees creating dancing patterns on the path. The elderly man feeding pigeons who smiled and nodded as they passed. The teenager walking his dog, earbuds in, but stopping to let Emma pet the golden retriever’s soft fur.

“Mummy,” Emma said, tugging at her hand, “you’re making a different face now.”

“What kind of face?”

“A happy one. Like you used to make.”

That’s when it hit her. Somewhere in her quest to manage time, she had forgotten to live in it.

The realisation felt like stepping out of a cramped, airless room into a vast meadow. Her chest loosened, her shoulders dropped, and for the first time in years, she felt like she could breathe properly.

She was fifteen minutes late to work that day. Her presentation went brilliantly anyway. And when her assistant asked about her “new morning routine,” Simone just smiled and said, “I decided to stop trying to catch time and started letting it catch me instead.”

That evening, she did something she hadn’t done in two years: she sat on her couch with Emma, no devices in sight, and read three chapters of Charlotte’s Web out loud, savouring the weight of the book in her hands and the feeling of her daughter’s warm body curled against her side.

The 5 Common Time Management Mistakes That Create Chaos Instead of Calm

1. The Multitasking Mirage

Simone’s first mistake—and perhaps the most seductive—was believing she could do multiple things simultaneously and do them well. Like many of us, she wore multitasking like a badge of honour, responding to emails during conference calls, planning dinner while reviewing reports, and listening to podcasts while helping Emma with homework.

The science is clear: our brains cannot actually multitask. What we call multitasking is really task-switching, and every switch comes with a cognitive cost. Research by Dr. Sophie Leroy shows that when we switch from Task A to Task B, part of our attention remains stuck on Task A—what she calls “attention residue.”

The Real Cost: Multitasking doesn’t just reduce efficiency by up to 40%; it increases stress hormones like cortisol and adrenaline, leaving you feeling frazzled and depleted.

The Alternative: Practice monotasking. Choose one thing and give it your complete attention. Yes, it feels uncomfortable at first—like mental decluttering, there’s initial resistance before the relief.

2. The Perfectionist Planning Trap

Simone’s colour-coded planners and detailed schedules weren’t organisation—they were anxiety management disguised as productivity. She spent more time planning her day than actually living it, creating elaborate systems that had to be maintained, updated, and perfected.

Perfectionist planning is procrastination in designer clothes. It gives us the illusion of control while keeping us stuck in preparation mode.

The Real Cost: Over-planning creates rigidity that breaks at the first sign of life’s natural messiness. When reality doesn’t match your perfect plan, stress skyrockets.

The Alternative: Plan for 70% of your day and leave 30% for life to happen. Build in buffer time. Accept that good enough is often perfect.

3. The “Yes” Addiction

Perhaps the most dangerous mistake is saying yes to everything that seems important while saying no to what actually matters. Simone said yes to every meeting, every request, every opportunity—except the ones that truly mattered, like reading bedtime stories or taking walks in the park.

We say yes because we’re afraid of disappointing others, missing out, or appearing incapable. But every yes to something unimportant is a no to something that matters.

The Real Cost: Saying yes to everything is saying no to your priorities, your energy, and ultimately, your peace of mind.

The Alternative: Before saying yes to anything, ask: “What am I saying no to if I say yes to this?” Make your nos as carefully considered as your yeses.

4. The Technology Tyranny

Simone’s phone wasn’t a tool—it was her master. The constant notifications, the urge to check email “just quickly,” the seventeen productivity apps that required their own management system. Technology promised to save time, but instead consumed it.

The average person checks their phone 96 times per day and receives 121 emails daily. Each interruption doesn’t just steal the moment—it steals the recovery time needed to refocus.

The Real Cost: Constant connectivity keeps us in a state of partial attention, never fully present for anything or anyone, including ourselves.

The Alternative: Create technology boundaries. Designate phone-free zones and times. Use aeroplane mode as a productivity tool. Remember: you control your devices, or they control you.

5. The Energy Ignorance

This is the mistake that nearly broke Simone: treating time as if it’s all equal. She scheduled high-focus work during her energy valleys and administrative tasks during her peak hours. She worked against her natural rhythms instead of with them.

Energy management trumps time management every time. You can have all the time in the world, but without energy, it’s worthless.

The Real Cost: Working against your natural energy rhythms leads to burnout, decreased performance, and chronic stress.

The Alternative: Track your energy patterns for a week. Schedule your most important work during your peak energy hours. Protect your energy as fiercely as you protect your time.

5 Key Takeaways

1. Presence beats productivity every time. The goal isn’t to do more things; it’s to do the right things with full attention.
2. Flexibility is strength, not weakness. Rigid systems break; flexible ones bend and adapt.
3. Energy is your most precious resource. Time is renewable; energy isn’t. Manage it accordingly.
4. Boundaries aren’t barriers; they’re freedom. Saying no to the wrong things gives you the space to say yes to the right ones.
5. Perfect plans are perfectly useless. Life is messy, beautiful, and unpredictable. Your systems should reflect that reality.

The Time Archaeology Journal

For the next week, practice “time archaeology”—excavating the truth about how you really spend your time and energy.

Daily Prompts:

• Morning Intention: “What’s the one thing that would make today feel successful?”
• Energy Check: Rate your energy level (1-10) every two hours. Notice patterns.
• Attention Audit: Track every time you switch tasks. What triggered the switch?
• Evening Reflection: “When did I feel most present today? When did I feel most scattered?”
• Weekly Review: “What patterns am I noticing? What wants to change?”

Bonus Exercise: The Priority Archaeology Dig

List everything you did yesterday. Next to each item, write:

• E (energy-giving) or D (energy-draining)
• 1 (aligned with my values) or 0 (not aligned)
• H (High impact) or L (Low impact)

Notice what you discover about where your time actually goes versus where you think it goes.

“The key is not to prioritise what’s on your schedule, but to schedule your priorities.” – Stephen Covey

“You can do anything, but not everything.” – John C. Maxwell

Further Reading

• “Four Thousand Weeks” by Oliver Burkeman – A philosophical approach to time’s finite nature
• “Essentialism” by Greg McKeown – The disciplined pursuit of less
• “The Power of Now” by Eckhart Tolle – Presence as the antidote to time anxiety
• “Deep Work” by Cal Newport – Focusing in a distracted world
• “Atomic Habits” by James Clear – Small changes, remarkable results
• Research by Dr. Sophie Leroy on attention residue – Understanding the science of task-switching

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: But what if I really don’t have enough time for everything I need to do? A: This question assumes all tasks are equally necessary. Challenge this assumption. Often, we don’t have a time problem; we have a priority problem. What would happen if you didn’t do the least important 20% of your tasks?

Q: How do I deal with a boss/family/situation that demands constant availability? A: Start with micro-boundaries. You don’t need to revolutionise everything overnight. Maybe it’s keeping your phone in another room for one hour each evening, or batching email responses instead of responding immediately. Small boundaries create space for bigger ones.

Q: Isn’t all this just privileged advice for people who have choices? A: Fair point. Not everyone has the luxury of complete control over their schedule. But everyone has some agency, even if it’s tiny. Sometimes the most radical act is taking five minutes to breathe mindfully or saying “I need to think about that” instead of immediately agreeing to a request.

Q: What if my productivity system actually works for me? A: If your system truly serves you (and you’re honest about this), keep it! The question is: does your system reduce your stress, or does maintaining the system create stress? Does it help you be present, or does it keep you constantly thinking about what’s next?

Q: How long does it take to change these patterns? A: Awareness can shift immediately—like Simon’s walk in the park. Behavioural change typically takes 21-66 days, depending on the complexity of the habit. But here’s the secret: you don’t need to change everything to feel dramatically different. Often, adjusting just one pattern can create a cascade of positive changes.

Conclusion

Simone’s story isn’t unique—it’s universal. We’ve all been caught in the productivity trap, mistaking busyness for purposefulness, confusing motion with meaning.

The most profound time management insight isn’t about managing time at all. It’s about managing yourself within time. It’s recognising that time isn’t a problem to be solved but a gift to be received.

When we stop trying to control time and start dancing with it instead, something magical happens. We discover that we don’t need more time; we need more presence. We don’t need better systems; we need better relationships—with ourselves, our energy, and our choices.

The goal isn’t to become perfectly organised. It’s to become perfectly alive.

As Simone learned that autumn morning, sometimes the most productive thing you can do is slow down enough to notice you’re living.

---

Are you ready to step off the hamster wheel of hurried living? Join me for a transformative Camino de Santiago walking retreat in the beautiful southwest of France. Over five days of gentle walking, mindful reflection, and storytelling workshops, you’ll discover how to trade stress for spaciousness and busyness for being. Our small groups (maximum 3 participants) create intimate spaces for genuine transformation. Because sometimes the best way to manage time is to walk slowly enough to remember you’re alive.

Learn more about upcoming retreats and begin your journey back to yourself.